P.K. v. Blinken

Last update: Aug 29, 2024 Filing Location: The U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia

As part of the Trump administration’s Muslim Ban, the Department of State denied diversity visas for individuals from the banned countries. This case challenges those visa denials as unlawful.

Case Number: 1:17-cv-1533
Featured Downloads

Status: Currently on hold as another case is litigated that involved the same issue of whether a court could order that diversity visas be issued after the fiscal year in which they were awarded.


Case Overview

At the outset of his presidency, Donald Trump issued an Executive Order which barred individuals from several Muslim-majority countries from entering the United States. He described this action as a Muslim Ban. NILC and co-counsel ultimately filed multiple lawsuits challenging different aspects of the Ban, including the legality of the Ban itself and, in this case, the application of the Ban to the diversity visa lottery.

In this case, NILC and co-counsel challenged the Department of State’s refusal to process visa applications for winners of the U.S. Diversity Visa Program lottery who hailed from the six Muslim-majority countries covered by President Trump’s Muslim ban.

The U.S. Diversity Visa Program provides an opportunity to a limited number of immigrants from countries with historically low immigration to come to the United States. Randomly selected winners receive a visa, provided that they satisfy the eligibility requirements and qualify under the government’s general rules for visas. At the time of this suit, only 50,000 diversity visas were awarded each year with an average of 16 million people applying each year.

Our Plaintiffs, lottery winners from Iran and Yemen, had their visas withheld by the Trump administration’s Department of State on the basis of the Muslim Ban. Diversity Visas expire at the end of the federal fiscal year in which applicants are selected. When the 2017 fiscal year expired, the district court dismissed our case as moot, despite the fact that our Plaintiffs were denied the opportunity to obtain a visa and enter the country.

NILC and co-counsel appealed this decision and an Appeals court reversed it, with the Court of Appeals holding that relief may still be available for denied applicants. We returned to the District Court and subsequently agreed to stay (or pause) the case, due to the upcoming change in administrations.

Once in office, President Biden did rescind the Muslim Ban, but did not provide a remedy for people denied diversity visas based on the Ban. In response, we sought to reactivate the case, however, the court decided to keep the case on hold as another case was being litigated that involved the same issue of whether a court could order that diversity visas be issued after the fiscal year in which they were awarded.

The Latest
Worksite Raids Resistance & Response – TIRRC & NILC Webinar Training Series

Worksite Raids Resistance & Response – TIRRC & NILC Webinar Training Series

Feb 12, 2025 This webinar series provides a comprehensive guide to responding to workplace raids, covering strategies for immediate crisis response, legal defense, media engagement, labor and civil rights violations, and organizational...

FAQ: Non-citizen Registration Requirement in Trump Day 1 Executive Order

FAQ: Non-citizen Registration Requirement in Trump Day 1 Executive Order

Feb 6, 2025 This FAQ explains the law and history of immigrant registration in the U.S. and explores what the current Executive Order provision might mean for immigrant communities.

Conozca sus derechos bajo la Constitución de EE. UU., sea quien sea el presidente

Conozca sus derechos bajo la Constitución de EE. UU., sea quien sea el presidente

Jan 31, 2025 Sin importar quien es presidente, todas las personas que viven en EE.UU. tienen ciertos derechos básicos bajo la constitución del país. Publicado originalmente en noviembre de...

Know Your Rights: What to Do if You Are Arrested or Detained by Immigration

Know Your Rights: What to Do if You Are Arrested or Detained by Immigration

Jan 31, 2025 This Know Your Rights resource provides general information on what to do if you are stopped, arrested, or detained by immigration or other law enforcement. Originally published in December...