The 5th Circuit has issued a decision on DACA.
Learn More

Doe v. Mayorkas

Last update: Aug 29, 2024 Filing Location: U.S. District Court for the District of Arizona

Class action lawsuit challenging the deplorable conditions in U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) holding cells in the Tucson sector, the second largest CBP sector on the southern border.

Case Number: CV-15-00250-TUC-DCB

Status: In 2020, the court issued a permanent injunction, barring CBP from holding individuals for more than 48 hours without providing conditions to meet detainees’ basic human needs, including access to a bed and blanket, showers, adequate food and water, and medical assessments by a medical professional.


Case Overview

In June 2015, the National Immigration Law Center, along with co-counsel, filed a class action lawsuit challenging CBP’s practices of subjecting adults and children to deplorable conditions within its Tucson Sector facilities.

The Tucson Sector is the second largest CBP sector on the southern border. CBP regularly detains people in what are supposed to be short-term detention facilities for longer than the 12 hours for which the cells were designed.

CBP held our plaintiffs in overcrowded cells set to unacceptably cold temperatures without blankets or mattresses, access to potable water or adequate nutrition, adequate hygiene and sanitation, and medical screenings.

In November 2016, we obtained a preliminary injunction, requiring minimum standards to be met for people detained in the Tucson Sector facilities for more than 48 hours.

In 2020, we went to trial and ultimately secured a victory in the case, with the court finding that the conditions in CBP holding cells were punitive and in violation of the U.S. Constitution. The court issued a permanent injunction, ordering CBP to follow the standards set out in the preliminary injunction going forward. The permanent injunction bars CBP from holding individuals for more than 48 hours unless CBP provides conditions of confinement to meet Detainees’ basic human needs, including access to a bed and blanket, showers, adequate food and water, and medical assessments by a medical professional.

NILC continues to monitor conditions in the Tucson Sector facilities to ensure the government’s compliance with the court’s order.

This case is fundamentally about how we, as a country, treat people and what consequences that treatment has in their lives. We stand firmly in our belief that all people should be treated humanely and with dignity, and not detained in conditions that put their health and safety at risk.
Alvaro Huerta

Former NILC staff attorney

The Latest
Know Your Rights: What to Do if You Are Arrested or Detained by Immigration

Know Your Rights: What to Do if You Are Arrested or Detained by Immigration

Jan 15, 2025 This Know Your Rights resource provides general information on what to do if you are stopped, arrested, or detained by immigration or other law enforcement. Originally published in December...

5 cosas que debes saber sobre la Ley Laken Riley

5 cosas que debes saber sobre la Ley Laken Riley

Heidi Altman

Jan 10, 2025 El proyecto de ley Laken Riley no es una medida de seguridad pública, sino más bien un ataque a las protecciones constitucionales establecidas que no contribuiría nada a la seguridad de las comunidades si se promulgara como...

Five Things to Know about the Laken Riley Act

Five Things to Know about the Laken Riley Act

Heidi Altman

Jan 6, 2025 The Laken Riley Act exploits personal tragedy to fuel anti-immigrant rhetoric. This bill is not a public safety measure, but rather an attack on established constitutional protections that would do nothing to keep communities safe if enacted...

Budget Reconciliation and Immigration Policy: Potential Areas of Impact for 2025

Budget Reconciliation and Immigration Policy: Potential Areas of Impact for 2025

Heidi Altman and Ben D’Avanzo

Dec 13, 2024 Republican leadership has stated they plan to move two major bills on reconciliation. This analysis provides an overview of the reconciliation process from the lens of policies that impact immigrants, highlighting the potential and limits of...